Foreword: Imagination and Fact : A Lover's Quarrel / Frank Ankersmit -- The Quarrel Begins? -- Romancing the Past : Presence and Intangibilities of History -- Reality of Representation, Reality behind Representation : History and Memory -- Whose Mandir? Whose Masjid? The Historian's Ethics and the Ethics of Historical Reading -- Afterword: The Quarrel Continues? / Mark Bevir and Ranjan Ghosh.