Introduction by Kelly James Clark and Michael Rea -- Commonsense skeptical theism / Michael Bergmann ; Response : Stephen J. Wykstra -- The varieties of accidental necessity / Thomas P. Flint ; Response : Thomas M. Crisp -- Singular propositions / Trenton Merricks ; Response : David Vander Laan -- Theory comparison in science and religion / Richard Otto ; Response : Bas C. van Fraassen -- Descartes and virtue epistemology / Ernest Sosa ; Response : Raymond J. VanArragon -- The nature of the atonement / Eleonore Stump ; Response : E.J. Coffman -- Causation and the mental / Peter van Inwagen ; Response : Robin Collins -- The providential usefulness of "simple foreknowledge" / Dean Zimmerman ; Response : Donald Smith -- Then, now and Al by Nicholas Wolterstorff.